Any of their albums is a winner. I love Pegasus!! HorsePower! And Happy Ending!!! I am of no help, I love love love them.
Samuel Flynn Scott is my fav!!!
He also has Bunnies on Ponies. (his other band) War over Water is a great song on the album The Hunt Gives Us Life.
One of my favortie TPF songs is Sally. For a start? try of course "Let Me Die a Woman" Their biggest hit...
I could go on and on...so go to their website and their MySpace page, there are videos there.
Answer to your question? ALL OF THEM!!! let me know what you think!
did I mention that I love them?